October 5, 2019

Dear Stack Exchange, Inc.,

We, the undersigned moderators of the Stack Exchange network, are extremely disappointed in your conduct over the past few weeks. It should be clear from the public feedback you’ve been getting that we’re not the only ones upset with you right now, but as a group of people who have invested a lot in the network, this is intended to be a digest of our collective opinions.

There was a time when the most valuable asset of the Stack Exchange network was the people who freely contributed their time and energy to build communities in support of its mission. Undoubtedly, there still is an element of that left, but as the company has expanded, its outlook on the network has become, necessarily, more corporate. Not all of us have realised the extent to which that has happened over the years we’ve been here. Not all of us have been able to fully let go of the connection to the company we felt we once had. It’s been tough to realize that Stack Exchange no longer seems to want community input the way it used to.

Why we are upset

Not all of us are upset about the same things, but we have identified common themes that underlie our concerns. While recent events have proved to be the catalyst for us to voice our disappointment, our concerns stem from a number of actions and the impression we’ve received of the company’s direction over the past year or more.

We are frustrated with how Stack Exchange staff, with some exceptions, have been increasingly disengaged from the team of moderators as well as the broader community. It used to be common to see staff posting on sites and on meta sites in both professional and personal capacities. Moderators were also seen as community liaisons, collaborating with staff on policy changes and communication. Stack Exchange staff used to be in the trenches with us, not only fighting onslaughts of spam and abuse, but teaching us, learning from us, and understanding how they could best support and protect us. Now many of them, including community managers, feel like strangers.

We are disappointed with the lack of responsiveness to community concerns. On Meta Stack Exchange, bug reports, feature and support requests go unacknowledged, sometimes for months or years, and some excellent posts never receive a staff response. Meanwhile, there have been cases when staff have responded to complaints on Twitter almost immediately, taking action without due process and without consulting with the impacted sites.

We are discouraged that there is apparently no longer a place for human judgement when it comes to enforcing the Code of Conduct and other policies. While there used to be space for flexibility and compromise under the goal of respect for all, the human touch has been lost to rigid inflexibility. This is especially important when we consider the very diverse backgrounds of the millions of people who make up the community.

We are disheartened because Stack Exchange has always told us over the years that the people here are the most important asset there is, and the contribution of the people who don’t just participate but volunteer their time to moderate is considered valuable. Stack Exchange has always told us it will back us up. Not only have we been descended upon from above, but one of our own – a moderator who has for years been regarded as an exemplar on Stack Exchange – has been summarily cast aside with little regard to process or to her own well-being.

Among the most serious mistakes made was that a staff member spoke to the press about a member of the community who participates here under her own name. That same community member is now described in the press with language that can be taken to imply she is an extremist and a bigot. This news article is now the top search report for her name, which may cause her serious issues in real life, with her friends, her family, and her career. In doing this, Stack Exchange has rewarded years of service by putting one of its volunteers in danger – and there’s now a very real feeling that we may no longer be safe on this platform.

We’d like to make sure it’s clear that none of us support interacting with people with anything short of complete respect. As moderators, we are responsible for upholding, promoting, and respecting the high standards that Stack Exchange has set over the years, and we stand behind Stack Exchange in its move to ensure everyone feels welcome and safe. We do not wish to diminish the harm that many marginalized groups have suffered on Stack Exchange in the past in our expression of displeasure here. We do, however, wish to make it clear that the same respect we’re working to ensure those disadvantaged groups receive is due to everyone on Stack Exchange, no matter who they are. We feel this wasn't achieved in Stack Exchange’s response to this issue; that is, ultimately, the root of why many of us are upset.

Moving forward

While Stack Exchange has attempted to apologise for some things, many of us feel their apologies have been inadequate. There is a lot of hurt felt by moderators that has not been publicly acknowledged by the company. We would like to see the company explicitly acknowledge and apologise for the shortcomings and failures that have occurred - the lack of bidirectional communication, the mishandling of situations, the failures to address the pain of marginalized and disadvantaged groups, and the unseemly willingness to speak to the press about matters of user moderation that do not need to be spread outside the network.

Even when apologies and acknowledgements have been attempted, they have come across as insincere and half-hearted or stopped short of actually apologising. Any commitments for future change have been vague, at best. In order for us to move forward and heal this rift between company and community we would like Stack Exchange to take concrete, visible steps towards changing the behaviour that has led up to this current conflict.

We would like to see a roadmap for how Stack Exchange will improve engagement with moderators and the broader community. We want to see a return to the collaborative model that made Stack Overflow as well as the other sites in the network successful in the first place. We want to see trust between the community, including the moderators, and the company restored.

We believe that it is important that the staff, especially those who engage with the community, are active members of the community, in the good times, not just during emergencies. The people in positions of community leadership must not be out of touch with the community using their product. We do not expect every member of staff to contribute all the time, of course, but we feel the current lack of engagement has been a major contributing factor behind many of our concerns. Being more visibly present will improve goodwill in both directions.

We want Stack Exchange to follow its own procedures when removing moderator privileges. We don’t want our fellow moderators to be removed without them even hearing a reason why. We acknowledge that this recent situation came from a slightly different angle than the existing policy is designed for, but absent any more pertinent policy, what already exists should have been adapted rather than it being made up on the spot.

We want Stack Exchange to follow the principles it set down for itself in “Our Theory of Moderation, Revisited” after the last fiasco. We want you to deliver on that promise to trust us, support us, and to give us agency, accountability, and autonomy. Ultimately, we want to feel that we are safe to disagree with Stack Exchange, even on matters of major policy.

We want to help, to serve our communities, rebuild, and move forward. Please take us up on our offer to give you feedback before you make public statements. We fully believe that each of the moderators of the Stack Exchange network have a deep understanding of their communities and can help you understand what public reaction will be before the company takes action. Using this feedback to set out with the best possible words and actions will truly help make Stack Exchange a more welcoming, inclusive space.

We recognise that Stack Exchange is in no way obliged to take our input. We know that we are guests in the home of a private company. We don’t own the platform, and while we want to help to steer the ship, we don’t have the right to determine how it is governed. What built this network is a sense of community and common purpose, and a big part of that has always been the close relationship and communication between Stack Exchange and stakeholders, such as moderators and users. It’s a shame that we’ve lost something so fundamental.


We, the undersigned, support the sentiments expressed in this letter, and join with its authors in asking that Stack Exchange take steps towards fostering community spirit once again.

Jon Clements
Oct 7

Paul White
Oct 6

Ben I.
Oct 22

Undo
Oct 6

ChrisF
Oct 8

0scar
Oct 30

Sam I am
Oct 6

whuber
Oct 7

Pᴀᴜʟsᴛᴇʀ2
Nov 14

Daniel Fischer
Oct 7

random
Oct 7

SEJPM
Oct 5

called2voyage
Oct 7

Scortchi
Oct 7

Journeyman Geek
Oct 5

Aloizio Macedo
Oct 9

Web Head
Oct 7

Sathya
Oct 7

anongoodnurse
Oct 6

ff524
Oct 6

L.Dutch
Oct 6

Peter Turner
Oct 6

Ghanima
Oct 5

Mathieu Guindon
Oct 18

lois6b
Oct 7

Tiago Cardoso
Oct 18

Murch
Oct 9

fedorqui
Oct 7

Emilie
Oct 5

thesecretmaster
Oct 6

Thomas Owens
Oct 5

Henders
Oct 8

rolfl
Oct 6

Mister Positive
Oct 7

Andrew Leach
Oct 10

ColleenV
Oct 7

jknappen
Oct 10

Hasan
Oct 20

DJMcMayhem
Oct 5

Wasabi
Oct 7

Mad Scientist
Oct 5

Madara Uchiha
Oct 5

HDE 226868
Oct 5

Oli
Oct 6

Frank
Oct 7

Alexander Gruber
Oct 5

Helmar
Oct 7

Doorknob
Oct 5

eykanal
Oct 7

ArtOfCode
Oct 5

Wrzlprmft
Oct 6

Michael Hampton
Oct 10

gbianchi
Oct 7

Danu
Oct 12

Nick Volynkin
Oct 12

Pedro Tamaroff
Oct 8

D.W.
Oct 6

slm
Oct 29

Dimitri mx
Oct 5

cag51
Oct 6

James
Oct 7

Pikoh
Oct 7

Mike Waters
Oct 10

GentlePurpleRain
Oct 7

Kevin
Oct 6

John Conde
Oct 6

DavidPostill
Oct 5

Joonas Ilmavirta
Oct 6

gung
Oct 7

nitsua60
Oct 6

goldilocks
Oct 8

Ganesh Sittampalam
Oct 5

kevinsky
Oct 7

Martin Tournoij
Oct 6

Ambo100
Oct 17

Snow
Oct 7

fossfreedom
Oct 6

Todd Trimble
Oct 7

Charo
Oct 6

Cerberus
Oct 5

prash
Oct 7

Bob Jansen
Oct 7

Lilienthal
Nov 15

msh210
Oct 5

Clive
Oct 7

jcolebrand
Oct 7

Anton Menshov
Oct 6

bellaj badr
Oct 7

Zhaph - Ben Duguid
Oct 10

TheSimpliFire
Oct 9

Midavalo
Oct 17

hazzey
Oct 6

Aurora0001
Oct 6

EhsanK
Oct 7

mattm
Oct 6

Stephen Rauch
Oct 6

Glen_b
Oct 7

Rubio
Oct 7

Michael Karas
Oct 8

0xC0000022L
Oct 14

fooot
Oct 7

Mego
Oct 5

Discrete lizard
Oct 6

sklivvz
Oct 7

topo morto
Nov 5

A J
Oct 7

Monty Wild
Oct 5

Mason Wheeler
Oct 6

iKlsR
Oct 16

heather
Oct 6

MadHatter
Oct 7

terdon
Oct 5

Hatchet
Oct 7

Schroeder
Oct 9

JoeTaxpayer
Oct 5

JamieC
Oct 6

Federico
Oct 7

Canadian Luke
Nov 4

jrg
Oct 6

Christophe Strobbe
Oct 7

Matthew Read
Jan 2

Jorge B.
Oct 7

hichris123
Oct 7

AJ Henderson
Oct 6

El'endia Starman
Oct 5

Denis Nardin
Oct 6

Mitch
Oct 6

Asaf Karagila
Oct 7

quid
Oct 6

dan
Oct 7

Xander
Oct 5

Cyn
Oct 13

Mark C Wallace
Oct 9

Rory Alsop
Oct 5

Daniil
Jun 21

Bryan Krause
Oct 7

Carey Gregory
Oct 8

Loong
Oct 6

Gallifreyan
Oct 6

Dan Hulme
Oct 15

Charlie
Oct 10

StrongBad
Oct 6

Suvitruf
Oct 6

Seth
Oct 5

David
Oct 11

egreg
Oct 6

julian
Oct 7

ByteCommander
Oct 6

gary.ray
Oct 29

Stéphane Gimenez
Oct 9

clabacchio
Oct 8

Christian Rau
Oct 5

yannis
Oct 5

Jamal
Oct 8

curiousdannii
Oct 5

Vogel612
Oct 5

AviD
Oct 6

Hohmannfan
Oct 7

Glorfindel
Oct 6

Mithrandir24601
Oct 6

yagmoth555
Oct 5

Ward
Oct 6

evpok
Oct 7

Gareth McCaughan
Oct 6

Maarten Bodewes
Oct 6

Massimo Ortolano
Oct 6

Isaac Moses
Oct 6

Simon Forsberg
Oct 7

Dennis
Oct 6

Caleb
Oct 7

Monica Cellio
Oct 7

user58
Oct 5

glenh7
Oct 7

Gilles
Oct 7

Tensibai
Oct 7

Robert Harvey
Oct 6

Ed Cottrell
Oct 7

Jeremy Banks
Oct 7

anonymous2
Oct 10

Mxyzplk
Oct 7

Daniel Pendergast
Oct 13

Mr.Mindor
Oct 7

Andreas
Oct 17

Everton Lenger
Oct 7

Notts90
Oct 7

Sundararaj Govindasamy
Oct 8

elemtilas
Oct 7

GermanNerd
Oct 21

March Ho
Oct 8

bryce
Oct 7

someone
Oct 18

Martijn Weterings
Oct 14

Wikis
Oct 17

Antti29
Nov 7

Austen
Oct 11

gdoron
Oct 15

Lars Huttar
Oct 9

isopach
Feb 5

Luke McGregor
Oct 7

paul-beverage
Oct 7

Ashish Ahuja
Feb 19

james-brewer
Oct 7

Hans Lub
Oct 7

Varun
Jun 30

OfftheCode
Oct 8

Pascal
Oct 10

GratefulDisciple
Oct 9

Zoe
Oct 7

Mat
Oct 8

Mike
Oct 23

Kaz
Oct 7

Kasper van den Berg
Oct 9

isaacg
Oct 18

tudor
Oct 7

SeanC
Oct 8

gomory-chvatal
Oct 19

thegrinner
Oct 14

reffu
Oct 8

MrZak
Oct 16

PM 2Ring
Oct 7

Emma Abdalla
Oct 22

Max0815
Oct 7

Agile_Eagle
Jun 26

Karan Desai
Oct 7

Spevacus
Jan 13

StoryTeller
Oct 8

l0k3ndr
Oct 7

DS9
Nov 11

Alinoor
Oct 7

guss77
Feb 24

Milo
Oct 8

zx8754
Oct 7

Voldemort's Wrath
Jan 14

Jonathan Leffler
Oct 7

jack
Nov 9

Radon Rosborough
Oct 20

Arrrstin
Oct 7

Toby Speight
Oct 7

Steerpike
Dec 18

CGCampbell
Oct 8

Sebastianb
Oct 18

Alexander
Oct 23

sourcejedi
Oct 11

Daniel
Oct 20

Andras Deak
Oct 6

Sean Vieira
Oct 7

godel9
Oct 7

BiosElement
Oct 8

10 Rep
Jun 25

aidanh010
Oct 7

BlackShift
Oct 15

Paul Griffiths
Oct 11

ZachSaucier
Oct 7

A.A.
Oct 7

calambarafael
Feb 23

Mercerenies
Oct 20

X-27
Oct 12

jeroen
Oct 8

mjoao
Oct 28

RoadWarrior
Oct 9

RBarryYoung
Oct 8

adil9
Oct 23

frans
Oct 9

RalphTheBest
Oct 11

Tom
Oct 9

Apollys
Oct 24

Bart van Ingen Schenau
Oct 7

Klors
Oct 29

jmick
Oct 7

Dan Masek
Oct 8

Mario Carneiro
Oct 9

Adam Lawrence
Oct 7

Ionuț-Claudiu Herciu
Oct 28

OnStrike
Nov 2

Parody
Oct 7

Pietro Saccardi
Oct 7

Evil Sparrow
Oct 7

DeltaLima
Oct 30

Baskakov_Dmitriy
Oct 16

Petter Friberg
Oct 7

legrojan
Oct 18

khalil
Oct 6

Ilmari Karonen
Oct 7

SmrtGrunt
Oct 7

weegee
Oct 17

code11
Jan 14

EKons
Oct 7

ckitching
Oct 22

Marnix Klooster
Oct 7

Erin Thursby
Oct 10

Chris Baker
Oct 9

ben
Jan 15

Domenic
Oct 7

Tranquilled
Oct 11

macbem
Oct 7

Guillermo Mestre
Oct 28

Bond
Oct 11

agucova
Oct 7

k0pernikus
Oct 12

cs95
Oct 7

L3viathan
Oct 7

joelostblom
Nov 5

Dennis T
Feb 20

JoL
Oct 7

polpak
Oct 28

amon
Oct 6

techturtle
Oct 7

Billy Jo Ayakatubby
Jan 6

Gabriel Romon
Oct 7

Don Thousand
Feb 20

bruh
Oct 7

Angew
Oct 7

flot2011
Feb 20

NobodyNada
Oct 7

Ashley Medway
Nov 7

Adrian
Nov 10

Konrad Rudolph
Oct 8

rxbudian
Oct 7

Eric Duminil
Oct 8

Steve Melnikoff
Oct 7

Adam
Oct 22

Autar
Oct 7

RedwolfPrograms
Oct 6

Marilou-A
Oct 6

JackRed
Oct 21

David Woitkowski
Oct 14

CrownedEagle
Oct 7

Sebastian Simon
Nov 18

connectyourcharger
Oct 7

AndrewRussellHayes
Oct 8

ABoschman
Oct 7

DK Bose
Oct 8

N Unnikrishnan
Nov 7

vela
Nov 5

MEE
Oct 7

Sybille Peters
Oct 19

Jacob C.
Nov 5

CptEric
Oct 24

knrumsey
Oct 8

Chris Olin
Jan 3

ktilcu
Oct 7

Sami Kuhmonen
Oct 11

Raphael Cruzeiro
Oct 7

Tiago Martins Peres
Feb 19

Aify
Oct 25

bogdan
Oct 7

tricasse
Oct 9

tripleee
Oct 7

Magisch
Oct 7

Johan
Nov 8

Venryx
Nov 12

Graviton
Oct 7

WGroleau (伟思礼)
Oct 12

84BombsJetpack
Oct 12

FryAmTheEggman
Oct 7

ballBreaker
Oct 8

AsieR_2
Oct 7

M--
Feb 19

Anoplexian
Nov 14

Starkeen
Nov 15

jmoerdyk
Jan 16

Knetic
Jan 15

Fabio Turati
Nov 19

Numeri
Oct 11

naive
Oct 7

David G
Oct 7

sourav
Oct 19

magnattic
Oct 18

ab2
Oct 8

Jehoshaph Akshay
Oct 18

sardathrion
Nov 12

Brock Adams
Oct 8

Makyen
Oct 7

Lewis
Oct 10

unforgettableid
Dec 27

Martin Bonner
Oct 11

7zark7
Oct 7

jimsug
Mar 2

brasofilo
Mar 16

Quill
Oct 11

Dada
Oct 10

Thunderforge
Oct 15

iCodez
Oct 12

muffin1634
Jan 17

Trasiva
Oct 15

Tonny
Oct 16

PinnyM
Oct 7

Paolo Forgia
Oct 8

I rarely use SO nowadays
Oct 12

Bee
Oct 29

tzaman
Jan 16

Manu
Oct 26

Joseph Malle
Oct 10

Garandy
Oct 21

yivi
Nov 7

manassehkatz
Nov 4

samcarter
Oct 7

Nathan L
Oct 8

thebjorn
Oct 7

zrajm
Oct 19

lucifer
Dec 31

Zesty
Mar 14

Esko
Nov 8

Geronimo
Oct 6

Fernando Matsumoto
Oct 7

NVZ
Oct 7

miku
Oct 7

Michael
Oct 7

rahuldottech
Oct 7

djsmiley2k
Oct 7

404
Oct 7

MultiplyByZer0
Oct 7

Davy M
Oct 7

djv
Oct 18

nwn
Feb 27

Cardinal System
Feb 26

Doctor Jones
Oct 7

Okami
Oct 7

vaxquis
Oct 8

DarkCygnus
Oct 28

angussidney
Oct 7

user.dz
Oct 26

Anuswadh
Oct 19

nightgaunt
Oct 8

Richard U
Oct 28

Johannes Kuhn
Oct 7

Noah Goodrich
Oct 15

Sam
Oct 8

Parth
Oct 14

Laure
Oct 9

a
Nov 10

rounin
Oct 9

Cerbrus
Oct 7

fretje
Feb 14

Josef
Oct 18

mbomb007
Oct 8

Matthias
Oct 13

alator
Nov 17

Sweeper
Dec 24

nikodunk
Oct 7

Paul Karam
Oct 11

happydave
Oct 10

svidgen
Oct 16

sasha
Oct 9

Karthi
Oct 10

Carlos Proaño
Oct 7

Lamak
Oct 7

Askar Kalykov
Oct 8

Kitten
Oct 10

stajs
Oct 8

cat
Oct 8

E_net4
Nov 10

Eric Wu
Oct 28

Evil
Oct 13

halfer
Oct 8

Standback
Oct 12

heemayl
Oct 21

Sean
Oct 7

Rohit
Oct 8

NSNoob
Oct 18

SecondFlight
Oct 8

rene
Oct 7

Vardoon
Oct 11

jme
Oct 8

Vincent Streicher
Oct 8

Luke Sawczak
Oct 9

Wayne Phipps
Feb 14

Javier
Feb 20

isuru
Oct 7

Hannele Ruiz
Oct 18

puzzlepiece87
Oct 7

giulio-caccin
Oct 19

Ferrybig
Oct 15

kuhl
Oct 7

Gerold Broser
Oct 9

infamoustrey
Oct 7

LinkBerest
Oct 8

Matthias Bauch
Oct 8

osuka_
Oct 12

Isaac
Oct 10

forest
Nov 2

TheCog
Oct 7

JYass
Oct 7

André Silva
Nov 14

mgetz
Oct 7

S.L. Barth
Oct 8

Taazar
Mar 2

AmaiKotori
Oct 10

Modus Tollens
Oct 7

Shailendra
Oct 7

Goyo
Oct 6

JonasCz
Oct 7

askrich
Feb 21

redanimalwar
Oct 7

Captain Squirrel
Oct 7

CypherPotato
Nov 8

Victor Stafusa
Oct 7

someone
Nov 13

RationalDev
Oct 8

attinat
Oct 9

oerkelens
Oct 11

Anthony Geoghegan
Oct 7

metersk
Oct 7

Jeff VanDyke
Oct 11

Richard
Oct 9

Bookwyrm
Nov 13

Scott Hannen
Oct 9

Davis
Oct 15

sfors
Oct 16

resueman
Oct 8

FireCubez
Nov 17

吖奇说
Oct 7

Kuba Ober
Feb 27

April
Oct 7

Benny Hill
Oct 7

chrylis
Nov 2

philipwhiuk
Oct 9

aloisdg
Oct 7

Chris W. Rea
Oct 8

Gonçalo Peres 龚燿禄
Feb 19

PotatoEngineer
Oct 8

Mr. de Silva
Oct 11

Erlend D.
Nov 15

Canon
Oct 7

r.uckus
Oct 17

Tran Tu
Jan 3

Rakete1111
Oct 7

Patricia Shanahan
Oct 9

John
Oct 22

Fausto NA
Oct 7

Marc
Oct 7

Raystafarian
Oct 7

Byron
Oct 7

ZekNikZ
Oct 26

haraldK
Oct 11

LemmyX
Mar 26

TheDarkWanderer
Feb 20

Houseman
Oct 6

Makoto
Oct 7

hunterloftis
Oct 7

Ludwik Trammer
Oct 7

Coronon
Oct 15

sinstein
Oct 17

vikingosegundo
Oct 7

aaaaaa123456789
Oct 16

CJ Dennis
Oct 9

Shaido
Oct 7

Greg Askew
Nov 9

Ḿűỻịgǻṇącểơửṩ ᛗ
Dec 23

Catch44
Oct 21

lumato
Oct 9

Cerise Saint Hilaire
Oct 9

JBT
Oct 23

Paŭlo Ebermann
Oct 20

yegle
Oct 7

Nic
Oct 7

stepheng
Oct 7

Hosch250
Oct 7

cpburnz
Oct 7

Steveo169
Oct 8

benknoble
Oct 7

Arkadiy
Oct 7

Suraj Rao
Oct 7

Bob Neumann
Oct 7

DaveyDaveDave
Jan 21

AProgrammer
Oct 9

ykay
Oct 7

fsb
Oct 18

DVK
Oct 7

ypercube
Oct 7

Gowtham G
Oct 7

PatJ
Oct 25

Jenny D
Oct 13

brhans
Nov 11

Sparker0i
Jan 14

BartoszKP
Oct 10

iBug
Oct 7

blonfu
Oct 7

marky1991
Oct 7

David Bowling
Oct 6

muru
Oct 7

Robert Grant
Oct 17

Lorenzo Donati
Feb 21

Toby Bartels
Oct 16

dwizum
Oct 16

dan1st
Oct 21

Ageax
Oct 15

Docteur
Oct 18

SpiritBob
Oct 9

Prabal Tiwari
Oct 15

double-beep
Oct 9

oppiniated
Jan 8

ElizB
Oct 7

Paulo Coghi
Nov 12

Kolappan Nathan
Oct 22

Tejas Shetty
Nov 6

Adam Davis
Oct 7

null
Oct 8

Tiwat
Oct 17

John Pirie
Oct 17

kuma
Oct 7

Brandon_J
Oct 16

Ben
Oct 31

user5226582
Oct 7

Nick A
Nov 12

Leon Meier
Oct 7

NordlysJeger
Oct 20

James
Feb 17

reece
Oct 7

Keale
Oct 24

dsignr
Oct 7

Jono 2906
Oct 9

Ashera138
Jan 14

Maybeso
Oct 12

Razvan Vacaru
Oct 7

Gryphon
Oct 6

FloPinguin
Jan 7

b degnan
Oct 7

biziclop
Nov 15

a3nm
Oct 12

Adam P
Oct 18

robau
Jan 15

Anne Daunted
Oct 7

TylerH
Oct 7

Jonathan Mee
Oct 24

T. Sar
Oct 9

iamnotmaynard
Nov 1

roberrrt-s
Oct 8

John Hascall
Feb 19

Shadow [Wizard]
Oct 6

Anton Sorokin
Oct 7

Sam Dean
Oct 11

Josh Caswell
Nov 10

reaanb
Oct 7

Eugene
Oct 9

JackNavaRow
Oct 7

Christoffer Lette
Oct 7

Linny
Oct 6

jhpratt
Oct 7

Phlarx
Oct 7

Michal Paszkiewicz
Oct 7

Peadar Ó Duinnín
Jun 10

Roijan
Oct 8

fennec
Oct 8

M.A.R.
Oct 7

ndugger
Jan 14

Galastel
Oct 6

Easymode44
Oct 7

O.O.Balance
Oct 7

Jon Harper
Oct 8

Amadan
Oct 28

JAD
Oct 9

Jon Kiparsky
Nov 4

Bob
Oct 7

osd
Oct 10

kylefairns
Oct 8

marvelings
Oct 23

dlatikay
Oct 8

VFDan
Jan 14

sox
Jan 16

Halcyon
Oct 7

Kiddo 9000
Feb 23

George M
Jan 15

fuz
Oct 28

pstrjds
Oct 7

Laf
Oct 8

lino
Jan 18

larry909
Oct 30

Rupinderjeet Singh Hans
Oct 8

Pluto
Oct 14

palash kulsh
Oct 7

kimball
Oct 8

pedrorijo91
Oct 7

Troyen
Oct 7

xfix
Oct 7

FelixSFD
Oct 7

briantist
Oct 9

Joel Reyes Noche
Oct 13

Josh Friedlander
Oct 22

motosubatsu
Oct 10

Pikachu
Nov 7

geisterfurz007
Oct 14

Bugs
Oct 15

b1oki
Oct 8

CaldeiraG
Oct 7

dublindan
Oct 7

Gavin Yancey
Oct 8

Mixxiphoid
Oct 18

Tivie
Oct 9

MechMK1
Oct 7

Remy
Oct 7

isherwood
Jan 16

Josh Junon
Oct 15

Secespitus
Oct 7

Martin
Jan 15

phyzome
Nov 7

Ari Brodsky
Oct 11

lankymart
Oct 12

scraimer
Oct 7

Gabriel Izaias
Oct 8

snowe
Oct 7

G.B
Oct 24

Pull Nointer
Oct 14

Ave
Oct 7

Draco18s
Dec 31

Max Vernon
Oct 7

Dɑvïd
Jan 31

WBT
Oct 24

Tony Vincent
Oct 7

awchisholm
Oct 10

castiblanco
Oct 27

bruglesco
Oct 9

gusmally
Oct 7

user10465355
Oct 21

TheAsh
Oct 28

Vatev
Oct 14

Tosindo
Nov 11

smci
Oct 9

IKM
Nov 7

Marc.2377
Oct 26

Pudora
Oct 11

Frisbee-horde
Oct 14

Stephen
Oct 9

Black Thunder
Oct 7

Zanna
Oct 10

GregD
Oct 7

Dan Neely
Oct 7

Dragonrage
Oct 7

LH16
Oct 7

chris.neilsen
Oct 7

kenorb
Jan 5

Flyto
Oct 7

Linnyarzar
Oct 23

Alexander Momchilov
Oct 13

Jimmyplay
Oct 8

Lux Claridge
Nov 18

Heslacher
Oct 7

JouleV
Nov 16

Raad
Oct 24

Redman
Oct 8

Chankey Pathak
Oct 7

James Wong
Oct 24

wimh
Oct 11

Nate Strickland
Oct 7

jcsahnwaldt
Oct 18

Athari
Oct 7

Obscerno
Oct 17

mrupsidown
Oct 14

fixer1234
Oct 6

Maya Posch
Oct 28

Kev
Feb 19

shamas-s-reinstate-monica
Jan 15

Jacob Raihle
Oct 14

Ben Miller
Oct 8

Servaes
Oct 20

Sampo Sarrala
Oct 7

Michael0x2a
Oct 7

Minding
Oct 8

Aaron
Oct 21

P.P.
Oct 24

Wowfunhappy
Oct 9

Avi Cherry
Oct 9

Esolanging Fruit
Oct 9

Allen Han
Oct 16

Gab
Oct 9

Shreyas Tripathy
Oct 29

Martin
Oct 7

Nick McCurdy
Oct 27

dezso
Oct 8

skbly7
Oct 7

Stevoisiak
Oct 7

litty
Oct 7

A_P
Oct 7

Chappo
Oct 8

DoMiNeLa10
Oct 22

pppery
Oct 7

Dennis
Oct 23

jackw11111
Oct 20

Zev Spitz
Oct 7

Jo King
Oct 16

g00glen00b
Oct 8

Arkane
Oct 8

Grey
Oct 7

Abhijit Parida
Oct 7

Berriel
Oct 17

anjanb
Oct 7

Crosbonaught
Oct 7

A
Oct 17

Paul Gregoire
Oct 7

John Omielan
Oct 7

The DIMM Reaper
Nov 15

mkt
Oct 7

pankaj-jha
Feb 13

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog
Oct 6

bjb568
Oct 26

Jonas
Oct 16

marcellothearcane
Oct 8

user45266
Oct 11

Nikola Yovchev
Oct 7

Marian
Oct 7

ento
Oct 6

user42701
Oct 7

Cardboard Box
Jan 14

fr_andres
Oct 22

Peilonrayz
Oct 7

Philippe
Oct 8

Digital Trauma
Oct 15

CullenJ
Oct 22

Jim Fell
Oct 14

allo
Nov 7

nvoigt
Oct 7

rodolphito
Oct 26

Eric
Oct 14

Shinobi_Atobe
Oct 23

Christian Gollhardt
Oct 6

Marco Borchert
Oct 7

mickeyf
Oct 8

Alan Montgomery
Oct 7

PEEJWEEJ
Oct 7

BenjaminUrquhart
Oct 6

creker
Feb 20

Md Ayquassar
Nov 3

Mike de Mello
Oct 8

Tim
Oct 7

Mr. Me
Oct 24

vincent-paing
Oct 7

edchum
Nov 14

Daedalus
Oct 18

Sandip Pingle
Oct 7

Alex H
Oct 8

dfhwze
Oct 8

LazarusL
Oct 7

bkiers
Oct 14

kay
Feb 21

Tom Minor
Nov 8

Zulan
Oct 14

Danield
Oct 7

silvascientist
Oct 18

Acarrera94
Oct 13

Mistella
Oct 9

CalvT
Oct 7

Ramhound
Oct 7

CollinB
Feb 21

Ikari
Oct 7

Unitato
Oct 15

GypsySpellweaver
Oct 7

Todd Wilcox
Oct 9

Sam
Dec 17

AndyT
Oct 8

User2013
Oct 7

reg
Oct 18

Martin Schröder
Oct 26

River
Oct 7

only_pro
Oct 25

orangecaterpillar
Oct 19